working
Credit to Hamza Butt: http://www.buynothingnew.org/2017/06/sole-treadmill-reviews.html licensed under Creative Commons

I recently joined a virtual job fair for autistic career seekers that included a connection to employers like Microsoft and other tech companies. I noticed one thing immediately: the recruiters were falling over themselves to recruit men (yes, only men) with technical and coding experience to get a job with their organizations. These men had other things in common, too. They were, most likely, very close to the definition of what Rosemary Garland Thomson calls the “normate” — white, heterosexual, middle-class, educated, male, and otherwise non-disabled (no other physical, emotional, psychological, or learning disabilities.)

By focusing on technical careers — careers that are already underrepresented for PoC, women, and other disabled people — these programs reify harmful stereotypes, overrepresent their positive impact on the community, and come very close to exploitation rather than support.

I spied a post by a young woman looking for a customer service, non-technical role with Microsoft. She received no answer whatsoever. A young man below her inquired about a data scientist position; a recruiter responded immediately, asking for his resume and sending him the direct contract information of a hiring manager. I then tried another chatroom for another major employer and sponsor of the career fair. Similarly, I discovered a post by a young man with an ethnic name searching for a non-technical career with the sponsor company. A recruiter with this respective company responded thirty-three minutes later telling him to send his resume into the void (a general e-mail address.) Exactly like the other board, young men with white-sounding names looking for technical careers were almost immediately contacted with specific connections to network themselves into a job.

We have known for quite some time that our sisters in the Autistic community have been under-diagnosed. The same is true for Autistic people of color. Moreover, Autistic people often have co-occurring disabilities that might include physical disabilities, sensory disabilities, ADHD, Bipolar Disorder, OCD, PTSD, learning disabilities, and more. Employment discrimination (including sexism, racism, and ableism toward co-occurring disabilities) has existed for some time, and there is little at work within Autistic employment programs to combat these biases. By focusing on technical careers — careers that are already underrepresented for PoC, women, and other disabled people — these programs reify harmful stereotypes, overrepresent their positive impact on the community, and come very close to exploitation rather than support.

Certainly, none of this is to say that programs like those at Microsoft can’t be successful, but we need to be more critical before we literally hand them more accolades (and associated business) without questioning what it is their program is doing — I mean beyond the weaponized, commercialized inspiration porn produced by their respective PR departments.

For people like me, people with a mathematics learning disability, a technical job is mostly out of the question. I certainly will never be a coder. However, that’s not to say that I do not have other skills, some of which are constantly touted by Autistic onboarding companies: excellent rote memory, superior analytical skills, natural organization and administration abilities, a good mind for policies and procedures, and ethical direction in work. On top of that, I have three college degrees. And I can confirm, as many have pointed out, that getting a job with a degree is even tougher being an Autistic adult than searching for low-paid, non-professional employment without one.

Certainly, none of this is to say that programs like those at Microsoft can’t be successful, but we need to be more critical before we literally hand them more accolades (and associated business) without questioning what it is their program is doing — I mean beyond the weaponized, commercialized inspiration porn produced by their respective PR departments. For example, the puff-pieces touted by Microsoft’s Autism hiring program feature all white, presumably heterosexual, cis-men who have found work through the program. One of the stories produced regarding the program mentions one woman working in customer support, and one video features a non-Autistic female with an Autistic son. No other Autistic women are mentioned, nor do they feature any Autistic people of color. Also, all the men work in data science or coding positions.

First, before we literally hand out more awards and accolades than actual people hired by Microsoft and similar companies, we need to ask about their demographics. How many employees have been hired? How many of these new hires are women, LGBTQIA, or PoC? How many have other disabilities?

To be clear, I am not communicating here that Microsoft isn’t attempting to do a good thing. Despite 35% of Autistic adults having a college degree or higher, the unemployment rate for Autistic adults with is 85%. Although the unemployment rates of adults with other disabilities is now dropping, they continue to be higher than the non-disabled community. Furthermore, the new employment opportunities for disabled adults appear to be mostly low-paying, menial jobs that no other employee wants to do. Before we start handing out humanitarian awards, and the related business entailed therein, we need to do our due diligence in asking critical questions.

First, before we literally hand out more awards and accolades than actual people hired by Microsoft and similar companies, we need to ask about their demographics. How many employees have been hired? How many of these new hires are women, LGBTQIA, or PoC? How many have other disabilities? What is the average age of these new employees? Next, we need to know more about the specific positions. What’s the pay rate? How does that compare to others with similar positions? Most importantly, do women and PoC get hired at similar rates for similar positions? Are all positions within the company available to and offered with the same eagerness to candidates within the program? Finally, what are the opportunities for advancement from the starting position?

As an Autistic person, I am, of course, concerned with the dismal state of employment for highly capable Autistic adults. We do need programs to help companies of all sizes (not just major employers) in all sectors to help hire, onboard, and keep disabled workers. But we do not need these companies to reinforce harmful (sexist, racist, and ableist) stereotypes.

Not only do we need to ask questions of the hiring company, but we also need to be critical of the onboarding companies that get paid a pretty penny to onboard these Autistic employees. First, these onboarding companies actual tend to do little to get Autistic candidates hired, contrary to their rhetoric. Related to the above, these companies often masquerade as charities — featuring puzzle piece imagery that Autistic people find dehumanizing and offensive and aligning themselves with Autistic hate groups like Autism$peaks. These companies are almost always owned and operated by non-Autistic and non-disabled “experts.” Like the aforementioned faux-charity, these organizations have learned to do very little to help any individual Autistic person while making a great deal of money for themselves, all while procuring massive amounts of undeserved public support.

I am aware that companies need to make a profit, and that we can easily sell companies on the idea that hiring more disabled workers is a win-win situation; however, because these companies are profiting, we need to be more critical with our praise — in some situations, the programs are more harmful than helpful. As an Autistic person, I am, of course, concerned with the dismal state of employment for highly capable Autistic adults. We do need programs to help companies of all sizes (not just major employers) in all sectors to help hire, onboard, and keep disabled workers. But we do not need these companies to reinforce harmful (sexist, racist, and ableist) stereotypes. We need these companies to affirm that they are aware of matrices of marginalization. Autistic people have multiple identities: we are sometimes LGBTQIA, African American, Latinx, Indigenous, or multiracial. Sometimes we have other disabilities in addition to Autism. Not only do we all, equally, need jobs; we need good-paying jobs in multiple roles with companies of all sizes and the opportunity to advance in our career. We need to hold programs like the Autistic employment program at Microsoft to higher standards. I do not support the Autistic hiring program at Microsoft, and I will not support it until I have honest, acceptable answers to all of the questions herein… and neither should you.

 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s